Texas Longhorns wide receiver Jake Smith (7) reacts after he drops the 1st down pass on 3rd down against TCU Horned Frogs defense of an NCAA college football game Oct 3, 2020; Austin, Texas, USA; at Darrell K Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Ricardo B. Brazziell-USA TODAY Sports

Cedric Golden

American-Statesman Staff


Golden: Texas gave away the chance for a Big 12 takeover with OU looming

Posted October 3rd, 2020

Story highlights
  • Texas dropped a 33-31 loss to TCU Saturday, its first of the season.
  • Running back Keaontay Ingram fumbled at the one-yard line in the final two minutes.
  • “The self-inflicted mistakes killed us," said quarterback Sam Ehlinger. We can’t make that many mistakes and expect to win.”

Texas gave it away on Saturday, and just like that, last week’s miracle on the South Plains has taken on lesser significance.

In tennis, it’s called solidifying the break. When you win a game on an opponent’s serve, you must then hold your own serve to make it mean something.

Texas did not. The Horns double-faulted away a win and ruined a great chance to stick their nose out front in the early part of Big 12 play.


Game, set, match, Frogs.

The Horns (2-1, 1-1) could have entered their annual showdown with Oklahoma as an unbeaten, top-10 team on the rise. Instead, after Saturday’s 33-31 loss, will arrive in Dallas with bruised egos, an uncertain identity and questions regarding their inability to work teams that they’re supposed to work.

TCU defensive players celebrate Keaontay Ingram’s late goal-line fumble in Saturday’s 33-31 upset win over Texas. (Ricardo B. Brazziell/American-Statesman)

On a day where they never found their cruising speed due their own ineptness, the Horns still could have won, but just like the Red Raiders the week before, they figured out a way to lose while on victory’s doorstep.

It would be easy to blame Keaontay Ingram for blowing it after he carelessly reached the ball out toward the goal line at crunch time with a half-dozen set of hands swiping at it, but this one doesn’t all fall on the shoulders of the same running back who dropped what would have been an easy touchdown in last year’s crushing loss to LSU.

Ingram had plenty of help — from his teammates, from his coaches and yes, even from the officials, who missed more calls than I care to count on a bad day at the office.

Really, this was a game that TCU should have won. The Frogs played cleaner from start to finish and made more clutch plays than the Horns, who came in as a 12-point favorite. Quarterback Max Duggan out-clutched Sam Ehlinger for the second straight year and TCU coach Gary Patterson continued his mastery of Texas, running his record to 7-2 since the Frogs joined the Big 12.

Texas’ D’Shawn Jamison opened the game with a 94-yard kickoff return, but it was called back by a Longhorns penalty. Texas was flagged 12 times in all. (Eric Gay/The Associated Press)

The Little General saved his team’s early season after a tough home loss to Iowa State and threw the league into a predictable logjam.

As for Texas, Ehlinger wore the face of a crestfallen team leader who was searching for answers that didn’t readily come when he was asked to gauge the feeling in the locker room.

“I would say ‘disappointed,’” Ehlinger said. “The self-inflicted mistakes killed us. We can’t make that many mistakes and expect to win.”

Ehlinger said he consoled Ingram in the locker room and told him that “it’s just a game” and not life or death.

That’s true on the surface, but similar sentiments aren’t being echoed in Tuscaloosa, Clemson or Columbus, places that have won national titles in the 15 seasons since Texas last danced among the national elite.

Call it what it was: A real soul taker for a title-starved fanbase that was hoping to comfortably settle in to top-10 status. The two-week stay was nice, but that’s over for now.

An entire listing of the miscues that kept the Horns from a 3-0 start for the first time since 2012 could fill a notebook, but here’s a sampling:

  • A holding call that erased D’Shawn Jamison’s 94-yard opening kickoff return.
  • The first of two ineligible receiver downfield penalties nullified a 47-yard catch by Ingram, leading to a punt.
  • Ehlinger’s second-quarter interception that came because he and Joshua Moore weren’t the same page on route.
  • Jake Smith’s third-down drop on a crossing pattern that would have gone for at least 20 yards midway through the  third quarter.

And let’s not forget the offense coming up empty one possession later after Joseph Ossai and T’Vondre Sweat teamed up for a strip sack and fumble of Duggan at TCU’s 36. The drive was quashed after tight tackle Christian Jones was whistled for being illegally downfield, nullifying Al’Vonte Woodard’s 26-yard catch to the TCU 11. The Horns had to punt.

Thankfully there isn’t any wallow time because the reeling Sooners — who just started 0-2 in league play with a loss at Iowa State —  are next up on the schedule. Coach Tom Herman knows he must get his leadership council in the right frame of mind because any head hanging could trickle down to the youngsters, and now is no time for self-pity.

“I do know that the want-to, the desire, the intensity level will be there,” Herman said. “It’s more of a matter of us again, finding a way to take the practice reps to the field on the field on Saturday. That falls on me. That falls on our the coaches and it falls on leadership of this team to make sure that we get that done.”

They had it in their grasp and it slipped it away.

We’ve heard that one before.

RELATED: TCU 33, No. 9 Texas 31: Another winnable game disappears as ‘this university deserves better’

RELATED: Golden: Texas gave away the chance for a Big 12 takeover with OU looming

RELATED: Bohls: Texas has a bad recent history to TCU — and rightly owns it after loss

RELATED: Texas-TCU notebook: Quest for late points unsuccessful, costly right before halftime

RELATED: TCU 33, Texas 31: The expanded boxscore

RELATED: TCU 33, Texas 31: Our five questions for the Longhorns — answered