The Dotted Line

Stay updated on the latest Texas Longhorns recruiting news brought to you by Longhorns recruiting beat writer Mike Craven of The Dotted Line will publish M-F at 10 a.m. each morning to provide Texas fans with an in-depth look at the latest for the Longhorns on the recruiting trail.

Texas uniforms sit on the sideline as players warmup before a Big 12 Conference football game at Royal-Memorial Stadium, Saturday, Nov. 17, 2018. [Stephen Spillman for Statesman]


The Dotted Line: Comparing the 2019 defensive recruiting classes of Texas, A&M, Oklahoma

Posted February 12th, 2019


Texas, Texas A&M and Oklahoma all finished inside the top 10 of the national recruiting rankings just once since 2000 — back in 2004. It was tougher when all three programs were in the Big 12. No two teams could eat without leaving the third hungry, but that changed when A&M jumped to the SEC and it amplified when the Aggies hired Jimbo Fisher.

Converse Judson defensive lineman DeMarvin Leal is the No. 3-ranked player on the Fabulous 55. (Mike Craven)

Oklahoma always recruits well in the state and four straight Big 12 titles offer Lincoln Riley and his Sooners a certain clout that the in-state schools simply can’t match. The SEC, rightfully or not, is a real selling point to young prospects who all aspire to reach the NFL and play for national championships. Fisher is the only in-state head coach who’s won a national championship as a head coach.

Tom Herman is inching Texas closer toward the golden years under Mack Brown after suffering through this decade with turmoil in the athletic office, the coaching booth and the locker room. Texas won 10 games, beat Georgia in the Sugar Bowl and signed back-to-back No. 3 classes for the first time in program history.


All three finished within the top six of the recruiting rankings in 2019 — Texas ranked third, Texas A&M fourth and Oklahoma sixth. There’s no real difference in the overall classes. The numbers are mostly arbitrary and came down to adjusted rankings after the 2018 season. We took a look at the offense yesterday and continue with the defense below. 

Defensive linemen

1. Oklahoma: (7) Derek Green, LaRon Stokes, Joseph Wete, Marcus Stripling, Marcus Hicks, David Ugwoegbu, Kori Roberson  

2. Texas: (4) Jacoby Jones, Peter Mpagi, T’Vondre Sweat, Myron Warren

3. Texas A&M: (3) DeMarvin Leal, Derick Hunter, Adarious Jones

Oklahoma has been one capable defense away from truly competing for the national title the past two seasons despite reaching the playoffs with a Heisman Trophy quarterback leading historic offenses. Oklahoma hopes it has addressed the issues on the defensive line with the 2018 and 2019 classes. A couple of this year’s seven commits could wind up at linebacker. Stripling, Ugwoegbu and Roberson are Texans and were members of the Fabulous 55.

Texas A&M’s defensive line class jumps the Longhorns if Braedon Mowry or Josh Ellison qualify and arrive on campus this summer. Leal is the best player in the group by a wide margin, but Texas gets the nod with a four-man class. Jones is a JUCO product who should help in 2019. Sweat and Warren are potential stars, while Mpagi is already on campus.  


1. Texas: (4) De’Gabriel Floyd, Marcus Tillman Jr., Caleb Johnson, David Gbenda

2. Texas A&M: (4) Andre White Jr., RJ Orebo, Ke’Shun Brown, Tarian Lee Jr., Christopher Russell

3. Oklahoma: None

The Oklahoma numbers could be misleading if one or two of the defensive end signees transition to the linebacker position. As currently listed on recruiting sites, the Sooners didn’t sign a single true linebacker prospect. That leaves the four-man classes signed by the Longhorns and Aggies.

Brown was the highest-ranked linebacker signed by A&M. The inside linebacker from Alabama is the No. 355-ranked overall prospect in the class. Texas’ signing of Floyd, a four-star ranked inside the top 70 in the nation, gives Texas the slight edge. Floyd is the true game-changer in this discussion with the numbers and talent-level even across the board.


Grayson High School’s Kenyatta Watson, left, was the first defensive back to commit to the Longhorns’ 2019 recruiting class. (Hyosub Shin/

1. Texas A&M: (2) Erick Young, Elijah Blades

2. Oklahoma: (2) Woodi Washington, Jaden Davis

3. Texas: (2) Kenyatta Watson II, Marques Caldwell

Young is a potential star whether he stays at cornerback or transitions to nickel or safety. He’s a big-bodied corner that won’t struggle with the physicality required to play the position in the SEC as long as his speed is on par. Blades instantly makes the Aggies’ secondary better with his 6-2 frame. He was the No. 1-ranked JUCO cornerback.

Second and third is a tossup between Texas and Oklahoma. Watson is the highest-rated of the collective four signees, but the duo of Washington and Davis are both considered national top-250 prospects in the nation. The wildcard is Caldwell, who missed most of his senior season with a labrum injury.


1. Texas A&M: (2) Brian Williams, Demani Richardson

2. Oklahoma: (3) Jamal Morris, Jeremiah Criddell, Ty DeArman

3. Texas: (2) Tyler Owens, Chris Adimora

Williams and Richardson were the top two safety prospects in the state and both chose Texas A&M early in the process. The two will fit well together in the Aggies’ secondary. Williams is a roamer who can cover and excels in zone coverage. Richardson is an enforcer who can play in the box or as a deep safety.

Texas’ group possesses a ton of potential in the athletic Owens and Adimora, but the floor is higher for the three signees in Norman. Morris is a versatile safety while Criddell is an athlete who should fit well in the Big 12. DeArman is a wildcard who is listed as an athlete and could end up at wide receiver.

The Big 3

AVG. RANK8.2312.617.95
The team recruiting rankings of Texas A&M, Oklahoma and Texas of each cycle as published by 247Sports composite.

Tomorrow’s Dotted Line: Commitment Q&A with 2019 offensive tackle Isaiah Hookfin