Syracuse Orange head coach Dino Babers (center) leads his team on the field prior to the game against Wagner at the Carrier Dome last season. (Rich Barnes/USA Today)


Our 11th annual Top 25 countdown: Was 2018 a one-time thing, or has No. 23 Syracuse arrived?

After three straight 4-8 seasons, the Orange bounced back in a big way last year.

Posted July 5th, 2019


We’re 55 days away from the 2019 season opener, but it’s never too early to talk college football. We kick off our 11th annual countdown series of our preseason Top 25 as selected by the American-Statesman sports staff. Last year’s eventual CFP semifinalists ranked 1st, 2nd, 8th and 13th in our 2018 poll.

Our No. 23 team: Syracuse

The Orange’s best-case scenario: The Orange won 10 games last year for the first time in 17 years, and they pushed eventual national champion Clemson before falling 23-17 in the Tigers’ closest ACC game of the season. If new quarterback Tommy DeVito can capture just a pinch of the magic shown by last year’s starter Eric Dungey, an impressive defense should help Syracuse secure another 10-win season.

And their worst-case scenario: Worst case? DeVito, an under-recruited redshirt sophomore who doesn’t boast the mobility of Dungey, struggles behind an inexperienced offensive line that must replace three starters. A stout defense can’t hold up under constant pressure, and the Orange drop back to the middle of the ACC pack.


Last year, Syracuse didn’t crack our preseason poll.

Inside the Orange

Coach: Dino Babers (4th year, 18-19; 55-35 overall, 7 years at Eastern Illinois, Bowling Green and Syracuse)

2018: 10-3, 6-2 in the ACC (beat West Virginia in the Camping World Bowl). Syracuse, picked to finish last in the ACC, was second in the ACC Atlantic.

Returning starters: 6 offense, 8 defense

Shoes to fill: QB Eric Dungey (2,868 yards, 33 total TDs); WR Jamal Custis (leading receiver); LB Ryan Guthrie (leading tackler); DB Klelan Whitner (2nd leading tackler)

Spring cleaning: Not only does the offensive line lack experience, but it’s also struggling with health. Several projected starters missed the spring game, where the offensive front was manhandled by the Orange’s powerful defensive line. … The Orange must replace their entire linebackers corps, but Babers — a former offensive coordinator at Texas A&M — extolled the play of Andrew Armstrong and Lakiem Williams during spring workouts. … Lightly recruited running back Jawhar Jordan, a freshman from Arizona, had two long touchdown runs in the spring game, although one was called back after a holding penalty.

Syracuse Orange defensive lineman Alton Robinson (94) sacks Pittsburgh quarterback Max Browne (4) during their game at the Carrier Dome on Oct 7, 2017. (Rich Barnes/USA Today)

Returning leaders

PASSING: Tommy DeVito (2nd on team), 44-87-525 yards, 4 TDs, 3 INTs

RUSHING: Moe Neal (1st), 155-869-5

RECEIVING: Sean Riley (2nd), 64-756-3; Nykeim Johnson (3rd), 41-565-4; Taj Harris (4th) 40-565-3

TACKLES: DB Evan Foster (3rd), 86

SACKS: DL Kendall Coleman (T-1st), 10.0; DE Alton Robinson (T-1st), 10.0

INTERCEPTIONS: S Andre Cisco (1st), 7; DB Christopher Fredrick (2nd), 3

Returning All-ACC players (5)

Offense: WR Sean Riley (3rd team)

Defense: S Andre Cisco (1st), DE Alton Robinson (2nd)

Special teams: K Andre Szmyt (1st), P Sterling Hofrichter (1st)


Robinson rising: Senior defensive end Alton Robinson, a familiar face to high school football fans in Central Texas, has taken a circuitous route to Syracuse while becoming one of the most feared pass rushers in the ACC. A star at Converse Judson, Robinson signed with Texas A&M out of high school but was released from his letter of intent because of a pending felony robbery case. He enrolled at Northeastern Oklahoma A&M and had 14 sacks as a freshman, which ranked third among all junior college players in 2016. After the charges were dropped, he joined Syracuse, where he has become a defensive stalwart in his two seasons at the school. Last year, Robinson 12 games and had 39 tackles and 10 sacks while earning second-team all-conference honors.

Defensive stars: Robinson is part of a ferocious defensive front that ranks sixth in the nation, according to Bleacher Report. Senior and three-year starter Kendall Coleman matched Robinson with 10 sacks, and junior Kingsley Jonathan had five sacks and six tackles for a loss while emerging as a key member of the line’s rotation late in the season. In addition, senior Brandon Berry looks primed for a breakout season.

Putting the lone in Lone Star: The Orange rarely recruit in Texas, and they only have one other player from the Lone Star State after redshirt freshman linebacker Tre Allison told last week that he planned to transfer “for personal issues.” The 6-2, 233-pound Allison, rated a three-star recruit out of Tyler John Tyler, initially flipped to Syracuse from SMU. He was expected to contend for a spot on the two-deep roster. The Orange’s roster also includes freshman running back Garrison Johnson from Manvel.

2018 national stat rankings

Scoring: 11th (40.2 ppg)

Total offense: 19th (464.8 ypg)

Passing: 31st (264.7 ypg)

Rushing: 36th (200.1 ypg)

Red zone offense: 21st

Time of possession: 46th (30:28)

Scoring defense: 64th (27.0 ppg)

Total defense: 87th (426.5 ypg)

Pass defense: 115th (264.1 ypg)

Rush defense: 63rd (162.5 ypg)

Red zone defense: 17th

Turnover margin: T-5th

The schedule

Aug. 31at Liberty
Sept. 7at Maryland
Sept. 14Clemson*L, 27-23
Sept. 21Western Michiganw, 55-42
Sept. 28Holy Cross
Oct. 10at North Carolina State*W, 51-41
Oct. 18Pittsburgh*L, 44-37 (OT)
Oct. 26at Florida State*W, 30-7
Nov. 2Boston College*W, 42-21
Nov. 16at Duke*
Nov. 23at Louisville*W, 54-23
Nov. 30Wake Forest*W, 41-24
* ACC game

The key game? Sept. 14, vs. Clemson. For whatever reason, the Orange have played Clemson tougher than anyone over the past two seasons. Syracuse beat the Tigers 27-24 in 2017 and almost pulled off the upset last year. A win in this conference opener would set the table for a run at the ACC title.

The last 5 years

20143-9 / 1-7— / —No bowl
20154-8 / 2-6— / —No bowl
20164-8 / 2-6— / —No bowl
20174-8 / 2-6— / —No bowl
201810-3 / 6-2— / 15thCamping World Bowl, W
Total25-36 / 13-271 bowl game (1-0)
Note: Ranks are that year’s preseason/final ranking.

Our Top 25 — so far

No. 25: Stanford will need its experienced defense to lead the way early

No. 24: Can Nebraska carry its end-of-2018 momentum into 2019?

No. 23: Syracuse

Our Top 25, by conferences

1 school:

ACC — No. 23 Syracuse

Big Ten — No. 24 Nebraska

Pac-12 — No. 25 Stanford

Coming tomorrow: Our No. 22 team

Want a hint?

It’s our second Big Ten team of the poll.